Skip to main content Skip to Search Box
Summary Article: Thomas, Clarence
From American Government A to Z: The Supreme Court A to Z

Charges of sexual harassment made the 1991 confirmation hearing for Supreme Court nominee Clarence Thomas (1948—), a prominent black conservative, one of the most tumultuous in the nation's history. When the Senate finally confirmed Thomas as the second African American to serve on the Court, the vote was the closest in more than a century. Thomas then staked out a position at the conservative end of the Court's ideological spectrum, calling at times for scrapping well-established, liberal precedents in areas such as civil rights, federalism, and individual rights.

Thomas grew up in poverty in rural Georgia. After his parents split up, he was raised by his grandparents. His early education came in segregated Georgia schools run by white nuns, and he graduated from a Catholic boarding school outside Savannah. Thomas worked his way through college and received his law degree from Yale Law School.

During President Ronald Reagan's administration, Thomas served as head of the Civil Rights Division in the Department of Education and then as director of the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC). While at the EEOC, Thomas strongly opposed affirmative action programs. In 1990 President George H. W. Bush appointed Thomas to the U.S. Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit. Sixteen months later, on July 1, 1991, Bush nominated Thomas to succeed Justice Thurgood Marshall, the first African American to serve on the Court.

Clarence Thomas

Source: Collection of the Supreme Court of the United States/Steve Petteway

During his confirmation hearing Thomas sidestepped senators' questions about his personal views, in particular on the abortion issue. Civil rights and women's groups strongly opposed the nomination. The Senate Judiciary Committee deadlocked, 7-7, on whether to confirm Thomas and then decided with only one dissenting vote to send his name to the full Senate without a recommendation.

Two days before the scheduled Senate vote, Newsday and National Public Radio reported that Anita Hill, a law professor at the University of Oklahoma, had told Judiciary Committee staff that Thomas had sexually harassed her when they worked together at the Department of Education and the EEOC. The committee reopened the hearing and summoned Hill as a witness. She gave a graphic description of what she depicted as Thomas's advances and suggestive comments. Thomas followed with an adamant denial; he called the new hearing “a high-tech lynching for an uppity black.”

The committee closed the hearing without resolving the conflict. After a contentious debate, the Senate voted to confirm Thomas, 52-48. The vote was largely along party lines: forty-one Republicans and eleven Democrats, primarily southerners, voted for Thomas; forty-six Democrats and two Republicans voted against him.

Thomas has voted with the Court's conservative bloc throughout his tenure but has been assigned relatively few majority opinions of major significance. Among his few major opinions were a 1997 decision upholding state laws for confining “sexual predators” in mental institutions, a 2002 ruling allowing random drug testing for any high school students participating in extracurricular activities, and a 2009 decision raising the burden of proof in federal age discrimination cases.

Thomas has been aligned closely with fellow conservative Antonin Scalia; they have voted together around 90 percent of the time. They share an “originalist” approach to interpreting the Constitution. (See original intent.) Even when in the majority, Thomas and Scalia have sometimes urged a more conservative stance than the Court adopted. In affirmative action cases, for example, Thomas and Scalia both called for a complete ban on the use of racial preferences. When the Court upheld racial preferences in university admissions in 2003, Thomas wrote a strong and highly personal dissent complaining that affirmative action created a “stigma” for all blacks. When the Court limited race-based pupil assignments by local school districts in 2007, Thomas expressed doubt, in a concurring opinion, about whether integration was “necessary to black achievement.”

Thomas has also called for overturning precedents expanding Congress's power in interstate commerce and allowing inmates to sue over prison conditions. He advocated changing the Court's doctrines to give greater protection to commercial speech and to make it harder to regulate campaign contributions. He also uniformly rejected pleas to set aside death penalty convictions or sentences and strongly backed law enforcement in criminal law issues. Thomas was the lone justice in 2004 to support the George W. Bush administration's claimed power to detain a U.S. citizen as a suspected terrorist without any hearing. When the Court struck down a ban on violent video games for minors in 2011, Thomas argued in a lone dissent that the First Amendment as originally understood gave minors no free speech rights except through their parents.

Thomas, who had been a Roman Catholic until he went to college, returned to Catholicism in 1995. With Thomas, Scalia, Anthony M. Kennedy, and the appointments of Chief Justice John G. Roberts Jr. in 2005 and Justice Samuel A. Alito Jr. in 2006, the Court had a Catholic majority for the first time in its history. (See background of justices.)

Copyright © 2012 by CQ Press, an Imprint of SAGE Publications, Inc.

Related Articles

Full text Article Clarence Thomas
Biographical Encyclopedia of the Supreme Court: The Lives and Legal Philosophies of the Justices

Birth: June 23, 1948, Pin Point, Georgia. Education: Immaculate Conception Seminary, 1967–1968; Holy Cross College, B.A., 1971; Yale...

Full text Article Clarence Thomas 1991–
The Supreme Court Justices: Illustrated Biographies 1789-2012

Keywords 16. William H. Rehnquist Court (1986-2005) 17. John G. Roberts Jr. Court (2005-) Collection of the Supreme Court of...

Full text Article Thomas, Clarence
Encyclopedia of Abortion in the United States

Clarence Thomas was appointed as an associate justice of the United States Supreme Court in 1991. While on the Supreme Court Thomas has revealed an

See more from Credo