Skip to main content Skip to Search Box

Definition: nature-nurture debate from Collins Dictionary of Sociology

the debate surrounding the question of to what extent behaviour is the result of hereditary or innate influences (nature), or is determined by environment and learning (nurture). Assessing the relative contributions of each is extremely difficult, since both interact continually throughout development. Historically each side of the debate has had its support, nativists believing in hereditary determination and empiricists in the dominance of the environment. See also CHILD DEVELOPMENT, INTELLIGENCE.

Summary Article: Nature-Nurture Debate
From The SAGE Glossary of the Social and Behavioral Sciences

An ongoing debate in psychology about the etiology of traits and behavior. It inquires as to the influence of genetic inheritance (biological nature) and environmental conditions (nurture) on personality and human behavior. This debate was much more clearly demarcated in the early 20th century, when behaviorism was prominent. Behaviorists argued strongly for the “nurture” side of the debate, asserting that all behavior is determined by learning and experience. Those on the “nature” side of the debate emphasized the role of biological processes in human development, arguing that human development proceeds through a series of genetically determined changes that unfold according to a biologically determined path.

Although the debate continues today, it is now a debate about emphasis; modern psychologists recognize that human behavior is influenced by a combination of genetics and environment and argue over the relative contributions of these factors to particular behaviors. Behavioral genetics is the study of how genes and environments work together to shape behavior; the research methods commonly employed to investigate these questions include twin studies and adoption studies. Evidence shows that genes account for about half of the variation observed in personality charac teristics, but whether genetics influences the develop ment of personality and behavior patterns depends largely on the environment in which a child is raised. Behavioral genetics also aims to identify the particular genes that contribute to hereditary behavior. However, this can be a difficult task; while some physical traits are determined by a single gene, many behavioral patterns and personality characteristics are driven by a complex combination of multiple genes interacting with environ mental factors. For more information, see Rose (2001) in the bibliography.

See also

Adoption Studies, Environment (sociology), Genes, Personality, Twin Studies

Copyright © 2009 by SAGE Publications, Inc.

Related Articles

Full text Article Nature vs nurture
Reader's Guide to the Social Sciences

Archives of General Psychiatry , 52/11 ( 1995 ) Current Directions in Psychological Science , 6/4 ( 1997 ) Flynn James , “...

Full text Article Nature and Nurture
The Brain Book: An illustrated guide to its structure, function and disorders

Nature and nurture are the two factors shaping the way the brain functions. Nature refers to an individual’s genotype—that is, the particular...

Full text Article Nature–Nurture Controversy
The Concise Corsini Encyclopedia of Psychology and Behavioral Science

The so-called nature–nurture controversy is a family of controversies about the relative roles of heredity (nature) and environment...

See more from Credo