Billy the Kid (1859–81) was born William Henry McCarty. The exact date and place of his birth are not known but are believed to have been sometime in 1859 in New York City, perhaps on the Lower East Side of Manhattan. The family's location and living arrangements between 1865 and 1873 also remain unknown. However, in 1873, the family moved to Santa Fe, New Mexico. Shortly thereafter, the family moved again, this time to Silver City, New Mexico, where, upon his mother's death, McCarty was uprooted and sent to live with a foster family. He worked odd jobs in a butcher shop and a hotel but was soon arrested and jailed for petty theft. Not wanting to be in jail, he orchestrated an escape. He then returned to his foster family, who promptly put him on a train to Arizona, where his stepfather lived. Upon arrival, his stepfather refused to allow McCarty to stay because of his status as a fugitive. With no home and with little money, he was forced to accept a low-paying position as a ranch hand.
McCarty committed his first murder around the age of 16 during a fight at a saloon in Camp Grand, Arizona. The victim, Frank "Windy" Cahill, had bullied McCarty in the past. During this encounter, the older, physically stronger, and more experienced Cahill gained the advantage. However, during the struggle, McCarty was able to reach his gun and mortally shoot Cahill. After this incident, McCarty returned to New Mexico, where he was given the nickname "Kid" because of his young age and youthful appearance. Unable to find work, he soon joined a gang called the Boys. The Boys, operating in Lincoln County, New Mexico, were hired by rancher James Dolan. Dolan was embroiled in a bitter dispute with rival rancher John Tunstall. Eventually, this dispute became known as the Lincoln County War.
The Boys, under Dolan's direction and as a form of harassment, began to steal livestock from the Tunstall ranch. The sheriff arrested some of the gang's members, including Billy the Kid, and jailed them. When Tunstall realized that Billy the Kid was not a hard-core rustler but just a boy, he offered Billy the Kid a choice—if he would testify against the other rustlers, Tunstall would hire him to work on his ranch. Billy the Kid gladly accepted. Hopeful for a better future, Billy the Kid changed his name to William H. Bonney. His employment, however, did not last long, since Tunstall was soon murdered by members of the Boys.
To avenge Tunstall's murder, Bonney and other Tunstall ranch hands banded together, creating the Regulators. Initially, the Regulators sought to use the law to their advantage but soon found it impossible to work through the existing court system. Increasingly, they took matters into their own hands, seeking vigilante justice. Eventually, they killed Bill Morton (leader of the group that had killed Tunstall), Frank Baker, and William McCloskey (a Regulator suspected of working for both sides). They also killed the sheriff and his deputy. These murders resulted in arrest warrants being issued for members of the Regulators.
Once warrants were issued, Dolan intensified his efforts to eliminate the Regulators. Soon, Dolan and his men surrounded a known Regulator hideout, trapping numerous members inside. The siege lasted for five days before Dolan ordered the house to be burned. Once the house was ablaze, Bonney took charge and had the men form two groups so that an escape could be attempted. As Bonney and the other members of the Regulators emerged, four were shot and killed. Their deaths effectively broke up the Regulators and ended the war. Once the Regulators disbanded, Billy the Kid was a fugitive on the run once again.
Eventually, when Bonney learned that a new governor had assumed office in New Mexico, he sought a pardon on his murder charges. In exchange, he offered to testify against Dolan, his ranch hands, and the Boys. The governor agreed. Bonney soon surrendered himself to the proper officials and testified; yet his testimony had little effect—each person who was tried was acquitted. Since Bonney was already in custody, prosecuting attorney William Rynerson put him on trial for murder, effectively making it impossible for the governor to follow through with his promise to issue a pardon. Not trusting the authorities or the court system, Bonney again escaped custody.
Over the next two years, Bonney spent most of his time in and near Fort Sumner, New Mexico. During this time, Pat Garrett was elected sheriff of Lincoln County and accepted the task of bringing Billy the Kid to justice. Garrett was familiar with Bonney's usual hideouts and arrested him on December 23, 1880, in Stinking Springs, New Mexico. Bonney was put on trial for murder, found guilty, and sentenced to hang. After sentencing, Bonney was transported to Lincoln County to await execution. On April 28, 1881, he escaped custody yet again, killing two jail guards in the process. He then left Lincoln County and headed to Fort Sumner. Accounts of what happened next vary greatly and are difficult to confirm. Yet most accounts agree that Garrett, while searching for Bonney on July 14, 1881, stopped to ask a citizen of Fort Sumner about Bonney's whereabouts. At just that moment an unaware Bonney approached. Garrett recognized Bonney and fatally shot him in the chest. Other accounts tell of Garrett waiting in ambush style, killing Bonney as he entered a darkened room. Billy the Kid is buried at the Fort Sumner cemetery.
See Also: Arizona; Frontier Crime; History of Crime and Punishment in America: 1850–1900; New Mexico; Posses; Rural Police; Sheriffs.
- Summary on the Life of Billy the Kid." http://www.aboutbillythekid.com/index.html (Accessed September 2011). "
- To Hell on a Fast Horse: Billy the Kid, Pat Garrett, and the Epic Chase to Justice in the Old West. New York: William Morrow, 2010.
- The Authentic Life of Billy the Kid. New York: Skyhorse Publishing, 2011.
- New Mexico Tourism Department. "Billy the Kid Territory." http://www.newmexico.org/billythekid/index.php (Accessed September 2011).
Related Credo Articles
Nickname of Henry McCarty who also used the name William H. Bonney as an alias. He was one of several cowboy outlaws involved in the...
Born in New York, he was raised in the west and is said to have killed his first man at the age of 12. He took part in the New...
US outlaw. He achieved legendary notoriety for his robberies and murders in the south-west, supposedly from the age of twelve. He was captured by...